Boyd Raeburn
Boyd Raeburn
Celluloid Improvisations Logo











Jazz On Film....General Topics



"Billy Eckstine and His Orchestra -
Rhythm In A Riff"

 

Acknowledgements
Consider this a case of musical archeology, with inference and circumstantial evidence occasionally replacing “solid proof”; where the memories of musicians ultimately prove as important as existing historical records! Here, after many years of research, is the story of the 1946 Billy Eckstine musical featurette Rhythm In A Riff.

I could not have completed this “archeological dig” without the help of many people, most notably my good friend and cohort in jazz film, Theo Zwicky, as well as the late and much-missed filmographer Klaus Stratemann. The three of us, in turn, relied upon the memories of a large number of musicians. First and foremost was Frank Wess, who screened the film in question forty years after appearing in it, and attempted to recall personnel and production details for me. In addition, the film (or stills taken from it) was shared with Dizzy Gillespie, Norris Turney, Nat Pierce, Percy Heath, Gus Johnson, lllinois Jacquet, Al Grey, J.C. Heard, Milt Hinton, Buddy Tate, Dexter Gordon and others, all of whom added to the meager information existing in print. It should be noted that Gillespie, Gordon and Turney played in the Eckstine band around the time the film was made!

A number of reference books were also consulted, all noted in the bibliography that follows the article. While these books added details to the film’s production history, none cited the source of any information, and must be considered with some reservation. Needless to say, without all of the above input this article would not have been possible!

Introduction
The importance of Billy Eckstine’s big band in the development of modern jazz is recognized by all historians who write about bebop. Only a few, however, note that in addition to the DeLuxe and National recordings (not to forget a series of AFRS Jubilee broadcasts), the band also appeared in a 30 minute featurette entitled Rhythm In A Riff. The soundtrack has been issued on CD, the film made available on videotape. As a result the music has made its way into discographies, with personnel information seemingly lifted from the ether (or conveniently compiled from adjacent recording sessions) .... although in no case is a source actually cited! Here, for the first time, we will attempt to set the record straight where this important film document is concerned.

The Producer: William D. Alexander
Prior to the mid 1940's there was only a limited African-American presence in the production of independent feature films and shorts, and next to none in the production of the standard “Hollywood bill of fare”; Oscar Micheaux and Spencer Williams are the most familiar names in the field of black cast films, with Williams rarely given the credit due him. Beginning in the mid 1940’s, however, a new personality enters the fray, William D. Alexander, who is ultimately responsible for more independent musical films than any other black film producer!

Born in Colorado and educated at Colorado State University and the University of Chicago, Alexander’s first work with film was apparently for the Office of War Information. Although best known for his black cast musicals and musical featurettes, Alexander also produced documentaries and television newsreels. Later in his career he was appointed the official “state film maker” for both Haile Selassie (Ethiopia) and William S. Tubman (Liberia). In addition to the above accomplishments, it should be noted that Alexander was the only black film maker to cross over to mainstream Hollywood, producing “The Klansman” for Paramount in 1974.

Associated Producers of Negro Motion Pictures
Recognizing that money could be made in the production of black cast films --- termed “race films” by both the black and white press throughout the 1930s and ‘40s--- William Alexander formed The Associated Producers of Negro Motion Pictures sometime in early 1946. Corporate offices were located at 212 East 49th Street in New York City.

Some sources, including Dr. Henry Sampson’s Blacks in Black and White, claim that Alexander announced the company’s formation in August 1946. However, other evidence suggests while Alexander may have made an August announcement to the press, the formation of the company was already a fait accompli well before this point in time. On the May 4 of that year, for example, Alexander met with George Allen (formerly Ulcigan) of the Soundies Distributing Corporation of America, and informed Allen that he had completed two one-reel short subjects, one featuring the International Sweethearts of Rhythm, and the other Lucky Millinder and his Orchestra; both, Alexander suggested, contained material that might be released as soundies, and such ultimately proved to be the case. Copies of both shorts were available for screening as early as May 7, 1946, and the Lucky Millinder short definitely credits the film to The Associated Producers of Negro Motion Pictures.

(It should be noted that my copy of the International Sweethearts of Rhythm short bears the credit “Associated Artists Productions,” although printed production file materials refer back to the Associated Producers of Negro Motion Pictures moniker.)

One month later, on June 6, plans for another series of films were well underway, with the bands of Count Basie and Billy Eckstine the intended stars! Only the completion of a two-reel short during the third week of June stood between Alexander and the Eckstine and Basie films! (This short, featuring Henri Woode’s fine band, will be the topic of a future article.) While the Basie film was never made --- perhaps the Dizzy Gillespie feature Jivin’ In Bebop produced in the fall of the year was a replacement of sorts --- the Billy Eckstine featurette soon passed from the planning to production stage.

Production - The Place
Before Hollywood there was New York City, and it is probably safe to say that film making was done in each and every one of its five boroughs! While we are perhaps most familiar with the amazing shorts that came out of the Vitaphone studios in Brooklyn and Paramount’s facility in Astoria, the old Edison Studios in the Bronx made equally significant film history.

Thomas Alva Edison had built his first studio --- the first film studio in America, for that matter --- in West Orange, New Jersey. Dubbed “The Black Maria,” the building rotated a full 360 degrees in order to orient filming to the best available light. In 1905 Edison erected a vast complex in the Bronx, where film making was to continue for many decades.

The history of the Edison Studio is a story yet to be researched and reported. It is probable that various independent concerns rented space at the studio over the years. For instance, in Jimmy Dorsey - A Study in Contrasts, Robert Stockdale comments that, “A few days later [in early 1935] the [Dorsey Brothers] band returned to 2826 Decatur [the studio’s location], up in the Bronx, the location of the studios of Electrical Research Products, to cut some more tunes for Associated Transcriptions.” While the studio probably changed hands many times over the years, what we do know is that by early 1944 the studio, or a portion thereof, was rechristened Filmcraft Studios.

While Filmcraft Productions was directly connected to the Mills Novelty Company of Chicago, and ultimately produced well over 500 soundies, it is not known if Mills owned the studio, or merely rented space from another owner. In any case, this site became the primary location for the New York production of soundies, as well as the filming and recording of independent shorts and features, advertising and industrial films, etc. Much of the East Coast production of black cast films during this period was completed at this location. While circumstantial evidence suggests that this was the production facility used by William Alexander for all of his films, we can be certain that at the very least Rhythm In A Riff was produced at Filmcraft Studios, 2826 Decatur Avenue, Bronx, New York City.

Production - The Time
Establishing an accurate date for the featurette’s production is a considerable problem, complicated by the fact that William Alexander produced a number of shorts and perhaps one feature during the period May-September 1946. In any case, we can probably come somewhat closer than the “June-July 1946” quoted in most discographies.

All previous speculation to the contrary, what we do know is that the sets previously constructed on at least one of the Filmcraft sound stages were “struck” (taken down) on June 25, with the intention to “build [new sets] Wednesday, June 26 for rental to Associated Producers of Negro Films, Inc. [sic] who plan to shoot Thursday of this week and possibly three days next week.”

While surviving production memos all point to the production of a film by producer William Alexander at the beginning of July, the film’s contents and featured performers are not noted anywhere! However, considering the total known output of Alexander’s company, as well as general “production standards and routines” within the independent film industry at this time, it seems reasonable to assume that the following information, quoted from a “studio activity report,” refers to the production of the Billy Eckstine featurette under consideration:


Monday, 7/1/6 - William D. Alexander, photography - 8 hours straight
1 1/2 hours overtime
Tuesday, 7/2/6 - William D. Alexander, sound - 8 hours straight
Wednesday, 7/3/6 - William D. Alexander, sound - 8 hours straight
1 1/2 hours overtime
Thursday, 7/4/46 - holiday
Friday, 7/5/46 - William D. Alexander, sound - 8 hours straight
At the present, and subject to change, the following is a summary of next week’s business:
Monday & Tuesday - William D. Alexander - photography

Now, the amount of photography noted above seems reasonable for a 30 minute featurette, but 25 1/2 hours for sound recording? A number of possibilities present themselves, including: errors in the studio report; incorrect interpretation of the studio report; difficulty in recording the orchestra or performing the arrangements, resulting in multiple takes of many tunes; and the recording of soundtrack material for more than one featurette.

Alternately, and possibly more likely, is the fact that the term “sound” might refer not only to the recording of the musical tracks, which would have been photographed (“sidelined”) at a separate session. (Remember that “filming to a pre-recording soundtrack” was the rule of thumb within the entire film industry at this time.) In this case “sound” might also refer to portions of the film that were filmed and recorded simultaneously, such as some of the “dramatic dialogue,” musical sections (scat vocals, close-up instrumental solos, etc.) for which syncing would be difficult, and so forth.

Ultimately, how do we establish a recording date for the Eckstine short? On one hand we have the “studio activity report” noted and detailed above. On the other hand, an article in Billboard (July 27, 1946) notes that “Eckstine just completed work on a 30-minute featurette entitled Rhythm In A Riff.” The same article refers to films made by Lucky Millinder, Henri Woode and the International Sweethearts of Rhythm. Assume for the moment that previous speculations are indeed accurate ..... that the Lucky Millinder and International Sweethearts shorts were completed by early May, and that the Henry Woode feature (which also might have included an appearance by the International Sweethearts of Rhythm) “wrapped” in late June. We can therefore conclude that, although the evidence from the studio report is purely circumstantial, it is fair for discographers to cite “probably July 2, 3 and/or 5” as the recording date for the Billy Eckstine featurette.

Production Commences
Preplanning for the featurette had probably started as early as May 1946. During the second week in June, with work well underway, William Alexander received a letter from Robert Franklin, Director of Advertising and Publicity for the Soundies Distributing Corporation of America, with suggestions of songs that might be used in the featurette and then later re-released as soundies:

A Cottage For Sale
I Cover the Waterfront
Long, Long Journey
I’m In the Mood For Love
I’ That’s the Way You Feel
Blowing the Blues Away

It certainly appears that Franklin was well aware of Eckstine’s recordings for National! And while none of his suggestions were ultimately adopted, a telegram six days later recommending the use of two of the “latest Eckstine record hits -- Prisoner of Love and You Call It Madness” was carefully considered, with both of the songs included in the featurette.

While much “film production talent” had long-since been drawn to Hollywood, there remained in New York a core of individuals who were highly capable of producing motion pictures of professional quality, be they intended for commercial release, industrial / advertising use, etc. To direct his film William Alexander turned to fledgling director Leonard Anderson. Although little is known about him Anderson was a talented young film maker, apparently white, who directed three films for Alexander, and produced Yiddish films in the 1950’s. (Henry Sampson’s Blacks in Black and White includes a review, quoted later in this article, that suggests one Maceo Birch as director, although Anderson’s name is present on my print of the film, and is credited in all other references to the film.)

Director of photography Don Malkames and editor Gladys Brothers were both cinema veterans, highly respected within their fields. Their professionalism helps give the featurette a thoroughly polished look, despite a rather limited budget. (While I wouldn’t dare guess at the film’s budget, it might be noted that three-minute soundies were routinely produced for $2,400, give-or-take a couple of hundred dollars.)

The only credit that must be approached with skepticism is the closing title card that pronounces “A New PRC Picture.” Referring to the “B” production company “Producers Releasing Corporation,” this credit was probably added to the 16mm home-use prints at a much later date ---- possibly replacing a “The End” missing from the master negative. It is present on most surviving collector’s prints and videotape releases of the film, and is cited in Stratemann’s Negro Bands On Film. No connection between Alexander and PRC has ever been suggested, and one certainly never existed!

For the record, the production credits for the featurette --- with many of the following individuals also working on other Alexander productions during this period --- are:
producer: William D. Alexander
director: Leonard Anderson
director of photography: Don Malkames
screen play: Les Hafner
film editor: Gladys Brothers
sound: Nelson Minnerly
make-up: Fred Ryle

Distribution
In the 1930’s black film maker Oscar Micheaux followed in the literal footsteps of other producers of independent and “exploitation” films, personally carrying his product from town to town, booking and advertising what may have been a solitary print of his feature film. By the 1940’s the distribution of black cast films was a bit more sophisticated, although far less effective than the so-called “vertical integration” of the mainstream Hollywood product where a studio produced a film, and then distributed it to theaters that they also owned.

On occasion there was a semblance of cooperation between the major studios and the producer of independent black cast films. Los Angeles-based Leo and Harry Popkin, the white owners of Million Dollar Pictures, produced a series of films starring popular Ralph Cooper (of Apollo Theater fame), and persuaded Lowes Theaters (read MGM) to book the films on the East Coast. Two important film concerns, Astor Films and Sack Amusement, emerged to distribute a great deal of the black cast product; other black cast film producers probably turned to the established “states rights distributors” which were already in place to deal with the “B” product released by Grand National, Producers Releasing Corporation, Screen Guild and so forth.

In 1945 pioneer manager and entrepreneur Berle Adams produced an important black cast short entitled Caldonia. While the content --- a slight story framing a handful of excellent performances by Louis Jordan and his Tympany Five --- was a formula long familiar to film makers and viewers, the film’s intent was somewhat more innovative. Adam’s planned to distribute the film to theaters where Jordan was soon to perform, thus preparing the audience for the artist’s appearance. The Louis Jordan short was distributed by Astor Pictures and, as noted in Billboard (July 26, 1946), “The movie trail blazed by Louis Jordan, whose Caldonia short has been a means of hyping his road take, is now to be followed by Billy Eckstine...which will be distributed according to the same principle which paid off for Jordan.” The article continues, “The Eckstine flicker will be planted to dovetail with his personal appearances on road tours. As often as possible he will hit town during the run of the picture, take bows between screenings, and otherwise try to boost one-nighter receipts.”

With limited options available to him, Alexander turned to Astor Pictures to distribute this featurette, if not all of his product. By 1946 Astor was a well-established and respected concern. Robert M Savini headed of the company, and had previously worked with the Dixie Film Corporation. Astor Pictures shied away from production ---- Caldonia was an exception to the rule ---- preferring distribution and re-release of both black and white “product,” most of it independently produced. Astor was especially prominent in the distribution of black cast films, and it was to Astor that Alexander turned for the release of Rhythm In A Riff.

The Cast
While the main focus of the film is certainly Billy Eckstine and his Orchestra --- the band is discussed in detail in the section that follows --- mention must be made of the other cast members. Babe Wallace plays Joe Corwin, “The Boss.” Helen, his assistant and friend, for whom Billy eventually falls, is portrayed by Sarah Harris. George, the secretary, is probably played by Ray Moore, although he is not given on-screen credit. The same is true of Garfield Love, who possibly plays a booking agent, and whose participation is suggested by Dr. Henry Sampson.

Emmett “Babe” Wallace had been active in black entertainment for a decade and a half by the time the Eckstine featurette was made, and had appeared in short subjects (Smash Your Baggage, 1933 and The Black Network, 1935) and feature films (Stormy Weather, 1943 and William Alexander’s The Fight Never Ends, 1947, which starred Joe Louis). In 1936 he toured England as a member of Lew Leslie’s “Blackbirds.” Three years later Wallace recorded as a vocalist with Skeets Tolbert and his Rhythm, and was performing on stage in Los Angeles as late as 1985! Wallace is obviously very comfortable in front of the camera, and delivers his line smoothly and naturally, as would a veteran of stage and film.

Of Sarah Harris nothing is known in addition to her appearance in this featurette, save that at one time she was married to Apollo Theater star Ralph Cooper! Her performance is somewhat stiff, suggesting that this may be her first (and perhaps only) film appearance. As noted above, Ray Moore’s name is not found in the opening credits, but is listed in Stratemann’s Negro Bands On Film and in other reference works on black cast motion pictures; the source of this information is probably the one-sheet advertising poster for the film, most recently reproduced in Kisch and Mapp’s A Separate Cinema - Fifty Years of Black Cast Posters. Moore was also a New York-based actor, and in addition to this short subject appeared in the black cast film Sepia Cinderella, 1947. Henry Sampson’s Blacks in Black and White adds the name Garfield Love to the cast list. Again, no such name is found in the opening credits, and the source is most likely the featurette’s one-sheet. It is probably Love who plays the booker, Mr. Jones, who “can’t use the band for six months.”

The singers and dancers were all very active on the Harlem and New York scene, and appeared primarily in nightclubs and theaters, although recordings and film dates were not out of the ordinary. Although this is probably Ann Baker’s only film appearance, she was no neophyte to jazz and band singing. Baker spent much of 1943 with Louis Armstrong’s band, although I am not certain if she was a regular “band vocalist,” or merely an added attraction backed by the Armstrong orchestra on any number of broadcasts in the spring and summer of that year. (Theo Zwicky comments: “I think Ann Baker was a regular with Armstrong in 1943, replacing Velma Middleton who was absent (maybe sick).” In any case, three years later Baker was the “vocalist with the [Billy Eckstine] band” (this according the Chicago Defender ), and is advertised prominently for the Eckstine bookings at The Regal Theater and Club Sudan in 1946. Baker was with the orchestra until at least February 1947, at which point she moved on to the Count Basie band, probably appearing as an added attraction on a series of theater dates, as opposed to a “regular singer” with the band.

It is possible that Ann Baker recorded on a number of occasions ..... but only “just possible.” Somewhere in my files, not available at the moment but taken from the liner notes for an old LP, is mention that Baker was a non-de-chanson for Ann Hathaway, a suggestion that is seconded in Lord. If this is the case, then Baker / Hathaway can be heard on a number of recordings (including a date under her name for Keynote in 1946), as well as on this film.


The dancers in this film, Al Guster and Nicky O’Daniel, Hortense “The Body” Allen, and the five female chorus line dancers --- and probably the extras who play the “members of the audience” in the nightclub scenes --- were probably supplied by the Harlem-based “Sun Tan Studios” (217 West 125th Street, New York City). Established by star football running back Fritz Pollard, this was a black owned and operated talent agency that provided singers and dancers for clubs and films. Hortense Allen and Nicky O’Daniel were proficient and popular dancers, with the former appearing on stage in both Chicago and New York during the mid 1940’s. Both Allen and O’Daniel can be seen in any number of black cast features and shorts, as well as in a handful of Panoram soundies from this period.

The Band
Billy Eckstine’s orchestra was truly a revolutionary performing unit, and its importance in the development of bebop is noted by all who write on the subject of modern jazz. My personal estimation of the band’s importance can be judged by the amount of background material included to this point in the article, where we finally attempt to establish the band’s personnel and soloists.

Unfortunately, no union reports and few production records are extant, and our identification of the band’s personnel is therefore “second hand.” According to Frank Wess, the same musicians (with one exception, and a couple of uncertainties) performed on both soundtrack and screen, so for the most part “what you see is what you hear.” While the personnel listed below cannot be verified 100%, a great deal of time and energy has gone into its compilation. This has been a difficult job, complicated by the fact that there was a great deal of turnover in the band during this period. A close look at the literature, as well as the established personnels on the National recording dates, indicate that many musicians passed through this pioneering orchestra in 1945-46, some recording and some not.

Some years ago I had the opportunity to share the film with Frank Wess, who was indeed on the band at the time the film was made; others who have screened the film for me and offered feedback include Milt Hinton, Al Grey, and Benny Powell. The late Klaus Stratemann corroborated many of Wess’s thoughts and added a few of his own. Last, my good friend Theo Zwicky shared stills with a number of musicians on the scene at the time the film was made, and added invaluable input; among the musicians he consulted were Dizzy Gillespie, Norris Turney, Nat Pierce, Percy Heath, Illinois Jacquet, Dexter Gordon, Gus Johnson, J.C. Heard and Buddy Tate. Theo also shared the personnel with Milt Hinton who, noting the presence of Hobart Dotson, King Kolax, Porter Kilbert, and perhaps others said that it was “not a New York band, but a Chicago band.”

Billy Eckstine - vocal, valve trombone and leader

In his notes for the Savoy “twofer LP” Mr. B and the Band - The Savoy [sic] Sessions, Ira Gitler writes, “At the onset of his band ... B. took up the valve trombone. Though he never attained the fluidity of a J.J. Johnson ... B was a spirited soloist whose technique never became polished enough to free him from the cliche.”

trumpets

The trumpet section is largely identified, with a few questions here and there. However, Theo Zwicky and I are largely comfortable with what follows:

trumpet, far left: Joe Stroud - I am not familiar with this musician, but since he was identified by Frank Wess, we can assume with some certainty that it is indeed Stroud! The only other reference to this musician that I can locate is in Bruynickx, where Stroud is noted as a sideman on a Cat Anderson band recording in New York City for Apollo, May 1947.

trumpet, second from left: Hobart Dotson - Long associated with the Chicago jazz scene, Dotson also worked on the West Coast with the bands of Wilbert Baranco and Gerald Wilson, with whom he broadcast (Jubilee transcriptions) in 1946. He was with Eckstine from the spring of the year through at least October 1946, and appears to be the main trumpet soloist with the band that made this featurette.

trumpet, third from left: probably Rostelle Reese (although Leonard Hawkins has been mentioned as a possibility) - There is a bit of uncertainty where this section trumpet player is concerned, with both Reese and Hawkins mentioned at various times. However, both Frank Wess and Dizzy Gillespie --- men who should know! --- opted for Reese. In addition, Leonard Hawkins can be seen in the series of soundies featuring Skeets Tolbert and his Band, and the man who appears in the Eckstine featurette does not look like the trumpet player on the Tolbert band. (Nor, incidentally, does he look like the trumpet player identified as Joe Stroud.)

trumpet, fourth from the left: King Kolax - Everyone seems to agree that this is King Kolax, long a fixture on the Chicago scene, who had at least ten year’s experience in Windy City jazz bands before working with Eckstine in the mid 1940’s. His high note ability is featured on “Second Balcony Jump.”

In summary, for discographers of the future, the trumpets in the band should be listed as follows, left-to-right:

probably Joe Stroud, Hobart Dotson, probably Rostelle Reese, King Kolax


trombones

The trombonists in this band have long entertained conjecture, and then more conjecture. Let’s try and set the record straight. Although he does not play in the section, Billy Eckstine is featured as valve trombonist on three numbers.

trombone, far left: Gus Chappell - The trombonist here is Gus “Junior” Chappell. Frank Wess was unable to identify this musician ---- Chappell hadn’t been associated with the Eckstine band in the past, and was possibly on the band for only a short time. However, Theo Zwicky shared a frame blowup from the short with both Dizzy Gillespie and Norris Turney, and they feel that it is Chappell. Theo also sent me a known photo of Chappell, which I compared with the musician in the film and now must agree: this is Gus Chappell in a very early film appearance!


trombone, second from the left: probably Carl Williams, but possibly Gerry Valentine - More conjecture here, with the two leading contenders being Carl Williams (according to Frank Wess) and Gerald Valentine (according to most discographies). My assumption is that many jazz film fans have looked at this film and assumed that it was Valentine, based on the fact that he played on and arranged for the band during this period. Neither Theo nor I have a photo of Valentine, so until further evidence surfaces, it is probably safe to go with Carl Williams.


trombones, third from the left: Alfred “Chippy” Outcalt (or Aulcalt) - It is nice to be certain with at least one of the trombonist, and Dexter Gordon, Dizzy Gillespie, and Norris Turney have all agreed that this is Outcalt.

trombones, fourth from the left: Howard “Scotty” Scott - This musician’s face and hairline are quite distinctive, and I rather doubt that he would be mistaken for someone else. A number of musicians have opted for Scott, and we must assume that they are right.

In summary, for discographers of the future, the trombones in the band should be listed as follows, left-to-right:

Gus Chappell, Carl Williams or Gerry Valentine, Alfred “Chippy” Outcalt, Howard Scott

saxophones

tenor sax, to far left: Gene Ammons - Everyone agrees that this is Jug, and a comparison of this musician with photos from the period, or slightly later, leaves no doubt!

baritone sax, second from the left: probably Leo Parker, but possibly Eddie DeVerteuil - While this identification has been suggested by Percy Heath and Buddy Tate, others have felt that this was Eddie DeVerteuil. A photograph of Leo Parker in the Delmark CD “Takin’ Off - Sir Charles Thompson” certainly looks like Parker but then again, I have not seen any photos of Eddie DeVerteuil. I think I’d go with Parker.

alto sax, third from the left: Porter Kilbert - Everyone agrees that this is Chicago musician Porter Kilbert. His son concurs, so there is no doubt in this case.

alto sax, fourth from the left: probably Robert “Junior” Williams - I am not familiar with this musician, and know next to nothing about him; nor can I find his name in standard discographies. William’s name has been passed from discography to discography, without any citation whatsoever, and I would generally assign the term “possibly” to the name, save for this qualification: Theo Zwicky reports that a number of musicians have suggested Williams as a probability in this position, so until something better comes along, I’ll go with Williams .... albeit with a “probably” attached.

tenor sax, fifth from the left: Frank Wess - Frank identified himself here, so all is settled, no questions asked!

In summary, for discographers of the future, the saxophones in the band should be listed as follows, left-to-right:

Gene Ammons, tenor sax; probably Leo Parker, baritone sax; Porter Kilbert, alto sax; probably Robert “Junior” Williams, alto sax; Frank Wess, tenor sax

rhythm

There are some problems with the rhythm section, some explained and some not. Theo Zwicky reports that among the photos and frame blow-ups in his possession, all shared in this article, at least one shows a pianist and drummer who are different from the musicians in the other pictures. The situation with the pianist is explained below, at least in part. I would suggest that it is quite possible that a publicity photos exists with a slightly differing personnel since the sideline sessions were completed on a number of days (see “Production - The Time” above). I’ll try to cover each discrepancy as it arises.

piano: probably Jimmy Golden (soundtrack); Louie Dunlap (sideline) - The regular pianists during the period were Jimmy Golden, Richard “Duke” Ellington and Linton Garner. Frank Wess, after viewing the featurette, felt that it was probably Golden on soundtrack. However, Wess reports that “the boys were drinking during the lunch break,” and Golden was unable to make it back to the studio for the sideline session. As a result, Louie Dunlap was called in to sideline at the piano. (Dunlap, you might recall, was referred to as follows on the 1931 Louis Armstrong recording of “That Lonesome Road.”: “Why, here's two little songwriters here, little Louie Dunlap, and Charles (unintelligible)...and what you think about that, they are smokin' a Louis Armstrong special cigar...more power to ya, boys!” )

However, remember that sideline photography took place over a number of days. It is quite possible that if Wess noted Dunlap early in the film (perhaps he recognized Dunlap in the rehearsal scene that opens the short, seated screen left, wearing a beret), he might well have not looked at the pianist as the film continued, satisfied that he had already identified this member of the rhythm section. Jimmy Golden might therefore have appeared in other scenes, filmed on other days, although I cannot make a visual identification. In any case, Theo Zwicky publicity photos and the film indicate two different pianists! Perhaps we can conclude, at least for the moment, that it is Dunlap at the beginning of the film, and Golden during the later “nightclub performances.”

guitar: Connie “Race” Wainwright - All sources are certain that Wainwright is the guitarist in the band.

string bass: Bill McMahon - Again, everyone is certain that Mc Mahon is the string bass player.

drums: Art Blakey - Blakey is certainly the “primary” drummer on the band. I have watched the featurette carefully, and have not noticed anyone else sitting in at any time, although a re-screening is now called for! While it is possible that I have missed the “second drummer” on screen, it is also possible that he sits in only for a publicity photo only. In any case, Theo Zwicky’s comments are important: “I still think there are two different drummer seen on the two stills .... one being Art Blakey for sure. Bassist Johnny Williams said, ‘You can see that the drummer is not the same on the two photos.’”

In summary, for discographers of the future, the rhythm section in the band should be listed as follows:

probably Jimmy Golden (soundtrack), Louie Dunlap and probably Jimmy Golden (sideline), piano; Connie Wainwright, guitar; Bill McMahon, sting bass; Art Blakey (probably all soundtrack recording and most sideline work) and one unidentified (probably sideline only), drum

The Film

Very little needs to be said about the film (beyond the music, that is), save that, as far as black casts film are concerned, this featurette is rather well made. The images are well photographed and the sound well recorded. The editing, set decoration, dialogue and continuity is thoroughly professional, and worthy of any of the Hollywood “B” production units.

In terms of plot, most story complications were sacrificed in order to spotlight the music. Leader Billy Martin’s band is “on strike” and about to fold, or at least find a new leader, unless Billy obtains work. He gets the opportunity to audition for Joe Corwin (Babe Wallace), and in the meantime falls for Corwin’s supposed girlfriend (Sarah Wallace); however, he is hesitant to take the job just so Helen can “get in good with the boss.” When it is discovered that Helen is free and available (she and Joe are “just friends”) the romance can proceed, and we are treated to the floor show that Billy has prepared for Joe’s club opening.

The Music
As noted below, the Eckstine band performs thirteen numbers in this featurette, all from its regular “book.”. The band is in fine form, and it is clear that they have been together for a while, playing nightly for dances and concerts. If there were newer musicians on the band, musicians reading their parts rather than working from memory, it is not particularly evident. This was a professional group, and the band swings hard. Solos, especially from the reeds, are more abundant than in most musical shorts. While we hear less from trumpet players King Kolax and Hobart Dotson, both Gene Ammons and Frank Wess (especially the former) are given time to stretch out, playing some of the longest improvisational statements in all jazz film to this point in time. Special praise must go to the section leaders, and to the rhythm section --- Blakey in particular; the sense of swing is strong, the cohesion of the rhythm section admirable; likewise, the ballads are played with feeling, and compliment Billy’s crooning in a most attractive manner.

The music played in the film, along with composer, arranger, vocal and soloist credits, is as follows:

(1) Second Balcony Jump (partial, behind opening credits) (Billy Eckstine-Gerry Valentine) (Gerry Valentine, arranger) - Billy Eckstine and his Orchestra
(2) unidentified tune (fragment only) (composer unknown) - Billy Eckstine and his Orchestra

(3) unidentified title (boogie woogie piano, behind dialogue and dance routine) (composer unknown) - five unidentified female chorus line dancers, probably accompanied by Jimmy Golden, piano

(4) (I Love the) Rhythm In A Riff (Billy Eckstine-Gerry Valentine) (Budd Johnson, arranger) It certainly seems odd that Gerry Valentine would compose a song, and then hand it over to Budd Johnson to arrange; however, this was apparently the case, according to Ira Gitler’s notes in the old Savoy “twofer” reissue of the National sides - Billy Eckstine and his Orchestra (Billy Eckstine, vocal) (soloists: Gene Ammons, tenor sax; Art Blakey, drums)

(5) You Call It Madness (Con Conrad-Russ Columbo-Gladys Du Bois,
Paul Gregory) (arranger unknown) - Billy Eckstine and his Orchestra (Billy Eckstine, vocal)

(6) You Call It Madness (fragment) (Con Conrad-Russ Columbo- Gladys Du Bois, Paul Gregory) - Billy Eckstine, a-capella vocal

(7) Second Balcony Jump (Billy Eckstine - Gerry Valentine) (Gerry Valentine, arranger) - Hortense “The Body” Allen + five unidentified female chorus line dancers, accompanied by Billy
Eckstine and his Orchestra (soloists: King Kolax, trumpet; Billy
Eckstine, valve trombone; Gene Ammons, tenor sax)

(8) Lonesome Lover Blues (Billy Eckstine - Gerry Valentine) (Gerry
Valentine, arranger) - Billy Eckstine and his Orchestra (Billy Eckstine, vocal) (soloists: Billy Eckstine, valve trombone; Frank Wess, tenor sax)

(9) Taps Miller (Buck Clayton) (arranger unknown) - Hortense “The Body” Allen, dance, accompanied by Billy Eckstine and his Orchestra (soloists: Hobart Dotson, trumpet; Frank Wess, tenor sax; Art Blakey, drums)

(10) I Cried For You (Arthur Freed, Gus Arnheim, Abe Lyman) (arranger unknown) - Billy Eckstine and his Orchestra (Ann Baker, vocal) (soloists: Billy Eckstine, valve trombone)

(11) I Want To Talk About You (Billy Eckstine) (Tadd Dameron, arranger) - Billy Eckstine and his Orchestra (Billy Eckstine, vocal)

(12) Our Delight (Tadd Dameron) (Tadd Dameron, arranger) - Billy Eckstine and his Orchestra - Al Guster and Nicky O’Daniel, dance, accompanied by Billy Eckstine and his Orchestra (soloists: Hobart Dotson, trumpet; Billy Eckstine, valve trombone; Frank Wess, tenor sax)

(13) Prisoner Of Love (Leo Robin; Russ Columbo, Clarence Gaskill)
(Gerry Valentine, arranger) - Billy Eckstine and his Orchestra (Billy Eckstine, vocal)

Release, Re-Release and Reviews
A specific release date has not been discovered in the trades, although the early July production date suggests a release in the early fall. This is supported by a curious review from the Houston Informer, quoted by Henry Sampson in Blacks In Black and White. Sampson cites the date of the article as November 23, 1946, which does not “square” with the statement within the review that the film is to be “released to the nation’s leading theaters early in September....” (The comments by the reviewer imply that he/she has seen a preview of the film, rather than the finished product. It is also possible that he/she hasn’t seen the film at all, and is working from press materials provided by Alexander, hence the inclusion of song titles that are not performed in the featurette.) In any case, the review of the film should be shared in full:

Billy Eckstine, the bronze singing idol, made his screen debut this week in an as yet untitled musical featurette under the auspices of the Associated Producers of Negro Motion Pictures. The Eckstine band which featured his entire band and songstress Ann Baker, was produced by Bill Alexander and directed by Maceo Birch [sic].
Unlike the majority of orchestra features, the Eckstine film was made sans the usual corny dialogue and meaningless story, but instead highlighted the singing maestro and his crew in a topnotch presentation of the song hits that have made the name of Eckstine a musical by-word from coast-to-coast.

Maestro Eckstine has starred in his vocal rendition of such popular favorites as “I’m In the Mood For Love,” [sic] “Prisoner of Love,” “You Call It Madness,” “Rhythm in a Riff,” and “Lonesome Lover Blues.” Ann Baker supplied the feminine charm in “I Cried For You” and “What Is This Thing Called Love [sic],” while the Eckstine band chimed in with such jump arrangements as “Taps Miller,” “Exactly Like You,” [sic] and “Second Balcony Jump.”

The Eckstine featurette, which will run approximately 25 minutes is slated to be released to the nation’s leading theaters early in September as the new company’s initial entry in the big-time motion picture producing field.
Despite his tremendous popularity, maestro Eckstine has never before been featured on the screen, although Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer moguls have long been trying to persuade him to give up his band to become Lena Horne’s leading man in MGM film musicals.

William Alexander was a shrewd businessman, and realized that there was significant potential in multiple-release of the material contained in the film. In fact, the production and structure of his films was certainly planned with this in mind! As a result, the following year six songs were subsequently excerpted and re-released as three-minute soundies: Rhythm In A Riff (released as a soundie January 20, 1947), Lonesome Lover Blues (2/3/47), You Call It Madness (2/10/47), I Cried For You and I Want To Talk About You (2/24/47), Prisoner of Love (3/3/47).

Klaus Stratemann (Negro Bands On Film ) also notes that six songs, presumably the ones re-issued as soundies, were assembled into a pair of one reel (ten minute) short subjects under the titles “Blue Harlem” and “Harlem After Midnight.” (It is not known which songs are performed in each of the two shorts. Stratemann continues, “A third montage of clips, which could be identical to either of the previous compilations, was titled BILLY ECKSTINE SINGS. It contained the following clips: Lonesome Lover Blues/Rhythm In A Riff/I Want To Talk About You.”)

A number of sources also refer to an Eckstine featurette or feature from this period entitled “Flicker Up.” It is credited to either Associated Producers of Negro Motion or Alexander Productions, and is said to star Billy Eckstine and Mary Lou Harris (Sarah Harris?). In any case, it is not known if this is a separate and distinct featurette, a retitling of the film under consideration, or a reediting of the featurette.

A Final Evaluation
While this featurette could never be mistaken for something from MGM, Paramount or Warner Bros., it is a thoroughly professional motion picture short. Compared to many blackcast musical films of the 1940s it must be ranked as one of the best made. More important, the producer and director realized that they were not sharing a story per se. They were interested in presenting music within a minimal “frame.” And what fine music it is .... well arranged, and played with finesse, fire and style, allowing us to not only hear a fine band in great form, but also to hear extended solo performances by at least two important tenor stylists, Gene Ammons and Frank Wess. With all of the talent available in the New York area, it is indeed fortunate that Alexander selected the Billy Eckstine band to provide the music for this film, since it has left us with a audio-visual legacy that presents bebop in the process of its birth!


And Some Closure

I have long threatened to begin writing articles on jazz film, and this is the first. Please share your feedback .... too much information, could have used even more, a big bore, fascinating history, or whatever .... and if your response is positive, I can try to make this a regular part of the IAJRC Journal.

And for those now interested in actually seeing this film, it is available on videotape, paired with another Alexander production, Jivin’ in Bebop. You should be able to locate it on the Internet at thejazzstore.com Let me know if you have problems locating the film and we’ll see what we can do!

Bibliography

Brown, Dale Billy Eckstine - A Discography (Joyce Record Club, 1996)

Bruyninckx, W. Swing Discography (publisher uncertain, various dates)

Gitler, Ira Billy Eckstine - Mr. B and the Band - The Savoy Sessions (liner notes, Savoy LP SIL2214)

Kisch, John and Mapp, Edward A Separate Cinema - Fifty Years of Black-Cast Posters (Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1992)

Klotman, Phyllis Frame By Frame - A Black Filmography (Indiana University Press, 1979)

Lord, Tom The Jazz Discography (Lord Music Reference, Inc., 1992-1999

Sampson, Henry T. Blacks In Black and White (The Scarecrow Press, 1995)

Stockdale, Robert L. Jimmy Dorsey - A Study in Contrasts (The Scarecrow Press, 1999)

Stratemann, Klaus Negro Bands In Films - Big Bands, 1928-1950 (Verlag Uhle & Kleimann, 1981)

periodicals consulted, all various issues and dates

Billboard Magazine
Chicago Defender
Houston Informer





Home Page | Vamp 'til Ready | First Chorus | Second Chorus | Bridge |
Third Chorus | Diminuendo | Coda
 

 
All Images & Text © 1999-2006 by Mark A. Cantor
Page Last Updated 9/27/06